Best Restaurants in St. John Island for Awesome Foodie Experiences

Best Restaurants in St. John Island for Awesome Foodie Experiences

Table of Contents

For many people, one of the most exciting aspects of travel is trying new foods and exploring different culinary traditions. From street food to Michelin-starred restaurants, there’s something uniquely satisfying about experiencing the flavors and aromas of a new place. And while exploring museums and cultural sites is a highlight of any trip, discovering the local cuisine can be just as enriching.

If you’re looking for an island destination that can provide memorable foodie experiences, St. John Island is the place to be. The island is famous for its gorgeous beaches, crystal-clear water, and lush greenery. But beyond its natural beauty, St. John has an equally impressive culinary scene that deserves exploring.

To help you plan your culinary adventure, we’ve compiled a guide to some of the top St. John Island restaurants. Whether you’re a seasoned foodie or just looking to try new flavors, this guide will give you a taste of this tropical paradise’s fantastic dining experiences. So, get ready to indulge in delicious food options and discover why St. John is a must-visit destination for any food lover.

Best Restaurants in St. John You Need to Try

SJI-Aerial View of St. John Island

Besides its breathtaking scenery, St. John Island has impressive food and drink offerings. Here are just some of them:

1. The Lime Inn

The Lime Inn is a popular restaurant that has been a staple of St. John Island’s culinary scene for decades. With its open-air setting, friendly service, and delectable menu, locals and visitors have been flocking to this establishment since 1984.

The restaurant’s menu highlights the island’s rich culinary heritage, featuring classic Caribbean dishes to experimental twists on traditional favorites. From the Camarones Nocturnos to the Tuna Mediterraneo, every dish bursts with flavor and will satisfy you.

Apart from the gastronomic food, the restaurant’s open-air setting is also a big draw for diners, providing a relaxed and casual atmosphere. The outdoor seating area has a casual vibe, with lush tropical plants and colorful flowers. This decor creates a vibrant and inviting ambiance for a leisurely lunch or dinner.

2. Extra Virgin Bistro

Extra Virgin Bistro is one of the romantic restaurants on the island, ideal for date night. Nestled in the heart of Cruz Bay, this farm-to-table restaurant features creative dishes made with locally sourced ingredients.

The menu at Extra Virgin Bistro is a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to sourcing only the freshest ingredients. They use these ingredients to create innovative and flavorful dishes that are a delightful fusion of Caribbean and international flavors. From the crispy calamari to the braised beef short rib, the chefs prepare each dish with care and attention to detail.

The restaurant has an extensive wine list featuring various local and international wines to complement the food. Its skilled mixologists also create craft cocktails that are as beautiful as they are delicious, with fresh ingredients and one-of-a-kind garnishes.

3. Morgan’s Mango

Operating since 1992, Morgan’s Mango is the perfect place for food lovers. The restaurant boasts an extensive menu of Caribbean and international dishes sure to tantalize your taste buds. Its lively atmosphere is ideal for those seeking a fun night out, with live music and creative cocktails adding to the festive vibe.

The restaurant’s menu caters to all palates, with a wide range of options that include fresh seafood, succulent steaks, and a variety of vegetarian dishes. They also pride themselves on sourcing their ingredients locally, ensuring diners taste the best of the island’s produce.

Morgan’s Mango’s bartenders are also known for their creativity, so no meal is complete without trying one of their signature cocktails. They make their cocktails from fresh juices and top-shelf liquor, but they also have non-alcoholic options so that everyone will have a good time.

4. The Longboard

One of the island’s top foodie experiences is The Longboard. The restaurant’s laid-back atmosphere and beachy vibes make it an excellent spot to unwind and enjoy a delicious meal with loved ones.

The Longboard’s menu is an exciting journey of flavors and textures that will take your taste buds on a culinary adventure. The dishes are a fusion of traditional Hawaiian, Asian, and Caribbean cuisine, resulting in a unique and delicious menu. Each dish is carefully crafted with balanced sweet, salty, and spicy flavors, making every bite a true foodie experience.

In addition to the scrumptious food, The Longboard hosts happy hour specials. From 2 to 4 PM daily, guests can enjoy discounted drinks and appetizers and relax after exploring the island. And with its beachfront location, the establishment provides stunning views of St. John’s turquoise waters and white-sand beaches.

5. Sun Dog Cafe

Sun Dog Cafe stands out among the St. John Island restaurants, offering a unique dining experience. The restaurant combines fantastic food, sustainability, and a laid-back atmosphere, making it a beloved spot among residents and tourists.

For those who are health-conscious, Sun Dog Cafe has plenty of vegetarian and vegan options and gluten-free and dairy-free choices. Their dishes are bursting with flavor and creativity that will satisfy even the pickiest of eaters. Furthermore, their chefs are passionate about creating food that tastes good and positively impacts the environment.

Sun Dog Cafe’s commitment to sustainability extends beyond its menu, with the restaurant’s decor and operations also reflecting its eco-friendly values. They make their decorations from recycled materials, and using energy-efficient appliances helps them reduce their carbon footprint. As a customer, you can feel good about supporting a business prioritizing sustainability while enjoying a delicious meal.

6. Cruz Bay Landing

Located in the heart of Cruz Bay, Cruz Bay Landing provides its guests with many restaurant services. These services include indoor and outdoor dining options, takeout, and event catering. The restaurant is famous for its breakfast dishes, including classic American favorites and Caribbean-inspired specialties.

Along with its breakfast menu, Cruz Bay Landing also offers dishes for lunch and dinner. As for their drink options, they cater to all kinds of customers with their extensive menu. They have both alcoholic beverages for those looking for a fun night out and coffee drinks for those seeking a caffeine fix.

Cruz Bay Landing is a place to enjoy great food and a hub for entertainment and nightlife. The restaurant has live music every night, featuring talented local musicians who play diverse genres. Overall, Cruz Bay Landing offers a great dining experience with delicious food, a lively atmosphere, and live entertainment.

7. Ekaete Pink Corner

Ekaete Pink Corner is a family-owned and operated restaurant located in Coral Bay. This hidden gem is known for its authentic food, affordable prices, and friendly service.

As one of the best restaurants in St. John, Ekaete features dishes that showcase the flavors of the Caribbean. Some of the most popular dishes include jerk chicken and curry goat. The restaurant also provides vegetarian options, which are highly recommended by regulars.

One of Ekaete’s standout features is its warm and welcoming atmosphere. You can find the restaurant in a colorful building with open-air seating that offers stunning views of the surrounding mountains. And since it is family-owned, the staff is friendly and accommodating and will often make recommendations based on guests’ preferences.

The Bottom Line

There’s no denying that one of the best parts of any vacation is getting to try new food. At St. John Island, there are plenty of opportunities for foodies to indulge in unique and delicious experiences. Whether you’re seeking Caribbean flavors, fresh seafood, or international cuisine, the island’s diverse culinary scene has something for everyone. On your next trip, visit these top-rated restaurants to elevate your foodie experiences while on vacation.

Satisfy your inner foodie by indulging in the restaurants of St. John Island.

St. John Restaurants are a hidden gem that visitors shouldn’t miss. Although the island is renowned for its pristine beaches and spectacular landscapes, its restaurants are also worth a visit. Through exploring these dining establishments, you can discover the island’s unique flavors while enjoying the warm hospitality of the locals. So, why not add a culinary adventure to your itinerary and experience St. John’s vibrant food scene yourself?

SJI-st john usvi
Back to Blog Index

Information

Services

Email Us

Historical

Museums

Learn More

The history of St. John is diverse and chaotic. Learn more about the lives of early settlers and how the area eventually became part of the National Park in 1957 at the Archeological Museum at Cinnamon Bay.

Other

Sites

Learn More

Some of the other attractions in St. John that could be of interest include the St. John Animal Center, Bordeaux Mountain Overlook, and the Elaine Ione Sprauve Library and Museum.

Reef Bay

Trail

Reef Bay Trail is the perfect way for you to discover the secrets of St. John’s ancient petroglyphs, sugar mill ruins, and tropical forests. This two-mile-long St. John hiking trail features a steep rocky path and lets you explore the inner depths of the island. Near its end is a freshwater pond.

Annaberg Hiking

Trail

If you want a relaxing experience, hiking on St. John, USVI, Annaberg Hiking Trail is the one to tackle. It’s more of a walk than a hike, so it’s excellent for first-time hikers and beginners. This trail contains paved paths that wander around the ruins of historical buildings. At the top of the trail, a stunning ocean view awaits you.

Water

Taxis

Learn More

Hire a personal water taxi ride to and from your destination. A relaxing and comfortable way to go.

Cruise Ship

Schedules

Learn More

A comprehensive list of the major cruise ships and their schedules, arrival and departure times.

Rentals

Car

Learn More

One thing to remember is that here people drive on the left side of the road. You may wonder if it is better to rent a vehicle in St. Thomas or St. John. Get the opinion of a local. There are several car rental companies to choose from.

Virgin Islands National

Park

Learn More

60% of St. John is a national park. This means that the island enjoys untouched beauty and splendor, preserved for many years, and will continue to be so for future generations to enjoy. 

Historical

Sites

Learn More

With its history as rich as its landscape, you can visit and explore the many plantation ruins and archaic buildings still existing in St. John.

Lind Point

Trail

This short St. John hiking trail is perfect for all ages. It’s the best trail for families looking to experience a great bonding experience while surrounded by nature. At the trail’s end, breathtaking Salomon Beach awaits. Should you decide to walk for another half a mile, you will witness the clear blue waters of enchanting Honeymoon Beach.

Award-Winning

Beaches

Learn More

St. John island has the best beaches in the Caribbean. Along the famous North Shore of St. John visitors will find several miles of award-winning national park beaches, each one more enticing than the next. Be sure to view our comprehensive Beach Guide.

Visit

BVI

Learn More

You can extend your exploration by visiting one of the British Virgin Islands near St. John.

Spas &

Salons

Learn More

St. John offers many ways to pamper and boost your spirit. Book an appointment with one of the salons, spas, and massage therapists in the area and feel rejuvenated like a whole new person.

Shopping

in Cruz Bay

Learn More

There are multiple shopping centers in St. John where you can shop till you drop and enjoy a search for that truly unique curio find.

Snorkeling

Under
water

Learn More

With many local shops on Cinnamon Bay and Trunk Bay offering rental equipment for snorkeling and diving, you will have no problem finding the right equipment for your aquatic adventures.

Scuba

Diving

Learn More

You can go scuba diving and experience the amazing aquatic world beneath the surface of the Caribbean Sea.

Hiking

Trails

Learn More

St. John has dozens of well-maintained trails where you can go strolling, running, or hiking while enjoying the tropical breeze and stunning views of the island.

Petroglyph Spur

Trail

Featuring a steep climb and narrow path, Petroglyph Spur Trail offers a bit of a challenge. However, the reward is indeed worth all the sweat and exhaustion. Aside from a freshwater pond, this trail offers viewings of petroglyphs from as early as 300 A.D. You might even see newly discovered ones.

Francis Bay

Trail

Francis Bay Walking Trail is among the easiest of St. John hiking trails to traverse, and it’s also wheelchair-accessible. While the vegetation is a little brushy in some spots, the views are undeniably picturesque. It also features the Salt Pond and a dry tropical forest for you to explore

Cinnamon

Bay

Cinnamon Bay is the longest stretch of white sandy beach on St. John Island. Private ceremonies can be held on the beach with a tranquil, relaxing and intimate atmosphere. There are no fees for entering or using the beach.Cinnamon Bay is the longest stretch of white sandy beach on St. John Island. Private ceremonies can be held on the beach with a tranquil, relaxing and intimate atmosphere. There are no fees for entering or using the beach.

Tektite

Trail

In 1969, NASA along with the US Navy and the Department of Interior (DOI) launched a study at Lameshur Bay to evaluate what would happen when people live and work underwater. The first structure that was built for this experiment was called Tektite, and the Tektite Trail follows the original quarter mile road used to deliver supplies to the aquanauts. Unmarked and barely visible, the entrance to the Tektite Trail starts at the bottom of the concrete paved road that leads to both Great and Little Lameshur bays.

The first Tektite experiment was a success and a second experiment, deemed Tektite II, was launched later that year that included the world’s first all-female team of scientists to live underwater. Tektite and Tektite II were each built of two cylindrical tubes about 12 feet wide and 18 feet high that sat 50 feet underwater throughout the mission.

Today the structure is gone, but the underlying foundation underwater remains, as does the trail to the entrance. The original base camp is now the Virgin Islands Environmental Resource Station (VIERS), located between Great and Little Lameshur Bays and run by Clean Islands International on behalf of the University of the Virgin Islands. Visit the Tektite Museum at VIERS for some cool artifacts from that crazy time in 1969.

Trunk

Bay

Trunk Bay is the most popular beach and considered one of the top beaches in the world. There is a $4.00 charge per person daily from 7:30am – 4:30pm. Trunk Bay is a picturesque location for weddings any time of the day. It is most noted for sunset weddings.

Hawksnest

Beach

Hawksnest Beach is a beautiful stretch of white sand. It is an unforgettable place for a wedding. It offers restrooms and a place to change clothes for the Bridal couple and their guests. Hawksnest Beach is best for morning weddings because the lighting is absolutely phenomenal for photographs. There are no fees to enter or to use this beach and there is plenty of parking. Ceremonies of St. John offers canopy and chair rentals.

Annaberg Plantation

Ruins

Annaberg Plantation Ruins was once a Danish sugar mill and plantation back in 1780. It was named after William Gottschalk’s daughter. Annaberg translates to Anna’s Hill. There are many charming settings for a wedding ceremony to be held within this elegant historical plantation with breathtaking views.

The ruins are open to the public and protected by the Virgin Islands National Park. If you are interested in having your wedding here you would want to schedule it in the early morning or late afternoon to avoid the heat. Since the plantation is open to the public, it can get very crowded during mid day.

Peace Hill

Trail

Clearly marked and accessible from North Shore Road (Rt. 20), the Peace Hill Trail offers far more than the obvious. A small parking lot allows for only about eight cars and is rarely full. Follow a wide path straight up from the parking lot to a flat knoll where lies an old sugar mill ruin. Great 300 degree view of the North Shore of St. John and across to the British Virgin Islands, those who only go this far are missing the best part.

From the parking lot on the way up to Peace Hill is an unmarked entrance to a half mile trail that takes you directly to Denis Bay beach. The trail and the west area of Denis Bay are park land, while the land to the east with a residential dwelling is privately owned. The west side of Denis Bay is the most interesting, with large black volcanic rocks, warmed sitting pools, and a small rocky island just off the shoreline with excellent snorkeling all around. Denis Bay also offers interesting sights and sounds. Boats cruise along the North Shore of St. John (Windward Passage and The Narrows) heading through Sir Francis Drake Channel to the British Virgin Islands, which can be seen from Denis Bay beach in the distance. Water crafts range from small motored dinghies to multi-hulled sailing vessels, and there’s never a shortage of things to watch. Visitors to Denis Bay beach are guaranteed an active view and a classic tropical beach environment.

Bordeaux Mountain

Trail

Heading down the Bordeaux Mountain trail is a breeze, and puts hikers at Little Lameshur Bay for a refreshing dip in the clear Caribbean Sea. Heading up, you’ll wish you had made other plans!

Bordeaux Mountain trail is accessible at the top of Bordeaux Mountain Road, from an often unmarked trail head, and descends steeply a little more than a mile to the bay below. Head west to the Lameshur Bay trail to get to Reef Bay, or head east down the road to Great Lameshur Bay. Remember, only the latter will have any jeep traffic, so if you’re tired and looking to hitch, don’t head to Reef Bay!

Europa Spur

Trail

Along the Lameshur Bay trail is a spur trail to Europa Bay, about a half mile in. When the Lameshur Bay trail reaches the Reef Bay trail, make a right up the Reef Bay trail just 50 yards to the Petroglyph spur trail, or make a left down the Reef Bay trail about a mile to the Reef Bay Sugar Mill ruins, Reef Bay beach and greater Genti Bay.

Yawzi Point

Trail

Surprisingly named for a disease called Yaws, Yawzi Point marks the location where natives who were stricken years ago were isolated. Accessible from the Lameshur Bay beach road (between Great Lameshur Bay and Little Lameshur Bay), the Yawzi Point trail is just over a quarter mile and offers hikers a great sampling of local vegetation and breathtaking waterfront overlooks.

Lameshur Bay

Trail

Almost two miles from Lameshur Bay to Reef Bay, the Lameshur Bay trail offers many points of interests to hikers. Accessible from the end of Rt. 107 (Lameshur Bay road), the trail is wide and wanders through deep forest for the first half mile, then follows a ridge called the White Cliffs for the second half, ending about a mile up from the water at the Reef Bay trail. Hikers will find massive hollow trees still standing, wild deer and mongoose, and dozens of different birds enjoying the day overhead. Hiking along the White Cliffs of Lameshur Bay trail will bring you into bright sun, so remember the sunblock when you pack that extra water.

Cinnamon Bay

Trail

One of the trails that are open year-round is Cinnamon Bay Trail. Dogs are allowed, but they must be on a leash. With its shaded loop, this trail is beautiful and pleasant to visit anytime. This trail offers a close-up look at the old sugar factories, echoing the island’s history.

L'Esperance

Trail

You won’t find this trail on the national park hiking maps for St. John Island, but L’Esperance is one of the most interesting. Catch the entrance to L’Esperance trail on the south side of Centerline Rd. (Route 10) about a quarter mile past the Virgin Islands National Park sign at Catherineberg. Round trip, the L’Esperance trail is almost six miles, so bring plenty of water and start your hike early in the day to ensure you will return before dark. L’Esperance trail follows the Fish Bay Gut, with at least four different ruins sites not seen by many visitors. The trail veers east about halfway down and crosses over the Mollendal gut along the Sieben Ridge and down to Genti Bay, the greater area of water of which Reef Bay beach lies just to the east. You’ve hiked this far, might as well walk on over to the Reef Bay Sugar Mill ruins, just beyond the forest line at the beach, and down the Reef Bay trail about a mile to the Petroglyphs spur trail.

Brown Bay

Trail

Untouched and unspoiled are two of the best descriptions for the Brown Bay Trail. While it’s among the list of St. John, USVI, hiking trails that are not very well-maintained, it has its own charm and beauty. It leads to a private shallow cove that offers a peaceful escape. You will see starfish, conch, and loads of fish there.

Johnny Horn

Trail

Considered a moderately challenging route, Johnny Horny Trail takes about two hours to complete. It features a clear path, thanks to the foraging feral donkeys and goats in the area. This trail is steep and exposed to the sun, so you might want to bring plenty of water and snacks to keep you energized. It leads to historical sites and amazing views.

Turtle Point

Trail

With the rugged natural setting of Turtle Point Trail, you are sure to experience refreshing tropical breezes and witness impressive views. It follows Hawksnest Point’s rocky shoreline and passes through a dry forest and coastal terrain. Along the path, there are strategically placed benches where you can sit and relax.

Salt Pond Drunk Bay Spur

Trail

If you’ve opted to head out to Salt Pond, one of the national park beaches along the south shore of St. John Island, and you’re looking for a nice surprise, hike the short Drunk Bay spur trail, which starts at the far east end of Salt Pond bay and follows the Salt Pond along the north side for a half mile to Drunk Bay. A flat, and sometimes hot, walk from Salt Pond, Drunk Bay offers visitors who make the trek a fun surprise.

While the rocky, rough shores of Drunk Bay are not conducive to swimming, the famous bay clearly supports, and some say prompts, creative expression. While you may not see them at first, look closely to discover dozens, then hundreds, of coral statues along the rocky beach. Using the various formations of coral along the shoreline, inspired visitors for decades have created a bevy of “coral people” using the stones to create heads, torsos, arms and legs. Partially shredded coconut for hair, sargassum weed for clothes, and crooked pieces of drift wood allow for unlimited artistic opportunities. Add your creative two cents and build your beauty at Drunk Bay.

Drunk Bay Spur

Trail

If visiting Salt Pond, take an easy, quarter-mile flat hike over to Drunk Bay. Drunk Bay shore is rocky with rough waves, but also has a surprise awaiting all who visit. It takes only some coral with a little flotsam and jetsam thrown in to make the island’s most creative outlet. Hike the short distance over to Drunk Bay to find out for yourself what everyone is talking about!

Ram Head

Trail

Being one of the most unique and visually stimulating St. John, USVI, hiking trails, there’s no way you should miss Ram Head Trail. This one takes you on a rocky path that leads to a blue cobble beach, the hillside, and then finally, an overlook that’s 200 feet above the Caribbean Sea.

Rental & Charter

Boats

Learn More

There are a number of boat rental places in St. John that offer various cruising options, including sightseeing tours, island hopping tours, and snorkeling and diving tours. Come and enjoy the dazzling blue waters of the Caribbean while observing the splendid views and relaxing in the refreshing sea breeze.